We decided to write on the topic of organic foods because we are seeing and hearing so much about it in the news, in stores, and in our classes. We thought that as future nutrition health professionals it would be beneficial to do some research and compile our thoughts on organic eating.
So organic food is food that is produced without chemicals (herbicides, pesticides), growth hormones, or antibiotics. Thus, it is supposedly more healthy for you because chemicals, such as pesticides, growth hormones and antibiotics have been shown to cause unhealthy side effects in some cases. Once not too long ago, organic food could only be found in small health food stores, but now it is present in almost every supermarket. As nutrition students, we believe that it is important to understand the pros and cons to organic foods because it is such a ‘hot’ topic in the media. We each chose a side and started thinking and looking...
Pros of Organic Foods (Fei)
Well one of the obvious pros of organic foods is that they are chemical free and contain no growth hormones. For me, this is the main reasons I would purchase organic food. We have all heard of the horror stories in the past related to growth hormones being associated with early maturity in girls and fertilizers being linked to cancer, so no wonder organic foods are becoming so popular! With the media’s stories about the health consequences of genetically modified foods and the huge amount of chemicals used in the mass production of crops, any consumer that listens to the news has likely thought about buying organic at some point.
This increase in demand for organic foods has lead to an increase in production of these foods. With this increase in demand and production the costs related to organic foods, which are usually higher, may actually begin to decrease to levels closer to conventional food items. This potential decrease in pricing can be seen as a possible future pro because organic foods would then be financially accessible to more people, especially those who cannot afford to buy organic right now.
Another point is that some studies have documented that organic foods, such as leafy vegetables and potatoes, are more nutritious because they contain more absorbic acid than their conventional counterparts (Magkos, Arvaniti & Zampelas, 2003). So, organic food can be safer and more nutritious than conventional foods.
In many ways I believe that organic foods are better for the environment. With the growing of organic crops, toxic chemicals are not release into the soil, thus the soil is healthier and more nutrient dense, and there is no worries associated with chemicals leaching into the drinking water and other water systems. In my opinion organic eating is a way of life, people that choose to eat organic may be more likely to also purchase local foods, recycle, use the composter, and other environmentally friendly practices (www.ota.com/organic/mt/consumer.html). From my past knowledge, organic farmers are more likely to be interested in environmentally friendly practices, such as renewable resources and sustainability, than conventional farmers. Doesn't it make sense that organic food would be linked to the whole 'green' initiative? I think it does!
I think organic foods have also become more accessible to communities through farmer’s markets and other community programs such as The PACT “Grow to Learn” Urban Agriculture Initiative, which was discussed in class. This initiative allows for organic food to be donated to food banks in the Greater Toronto Area. Students help to grow the organic food used for this program, so it not only focuses on community building, but it also helps youth learn about the food system and provide organic foods to people that may not be able to afford them. I believe that this is a great example of an initiative that intertwines many different issues, such as community, organic foods, and educating the youth of future generations. I also found a news article regarding new organic certification in Canada through the Agricultural Justice Program. This new form of certification is suppose to promote equality between farm workers and employers, fair wages and enable fair contractual agreements between organic farmers and retailers. The development of this type of certification for organic food production demonstrates that the issue of equality and fair trade of organic foods is recognized in Canada.
In summary, I think organic foods are safer and more environmentally friendly than the conventional foods found in the grocery store. I know that organic farming could be viewed as a means for large companies to make a large profit, but the concept behind organic farming is also important to remember. I believe organic foods promote a more environmentally friendly lifestyle that is less centered around mass production and more centered around sustainability, community and safety.
Cons of Organic Foods (Trudy)
I think one of the most apparent cons of organic foods is the price. If you walk into any grocery store and compare the price of almost any product, the organic product is usually significantly more. This price differential can make organic foods financially inaccessible to people with lower incomes. This can then create an inequality between the people that can afford to eat organically and those who cannot. How would you feel if you were a single mother of two, with a low paying job and you were told that your children would should eat organically? Personally, I would feel guilty because organic foods would be financially inaccessible to my children. Thus unless community programs are put in place that help lower income, food insecure individuals obtain organic foods, I feel that it creates just another inequality between the rich and the poor. This also brings me to the point as to whether or not organic food is even safer or more nutritious than conventional food? I know that the production of organic foods does not involve chemicals, growth hormones and antibiotics, but does that really mean that organic foods are more nutritious or even safer? I know there are very strict laws in North America that control the use of pesticides and other fertilizers on produce brought into the country. Moreover, the antibiotics and growth hormones used on cattle, pigs and other animals used for human consumption are strictly tested for side effects and possible disease outcomes before they are used. So, to say that conventional food is not safe would not necessary be true. My parents and other relatives have all eaten non-organic food for their entire lives and they have yet to have suffered from any direct health consequences of eating conventional food.
I have also read in many magazines and news articles that certain vegetables and fruits may be ‘cleaner or less contaminated’ than others, thus is their organic version really needed? For example, I once read that broccoli does not need to be bought organically because it is not as contaminated as other vegetables. I think it was related to the fact that few insect pests feed on broccoli, thus less pesticides are used to a lesser degree on this vegetable. So, in some cases there is little to no difference in chemical ‘contamination’ between the organic and conventional versions.
***As a side note, I personally found food a chart in a magazine a few years ago which contained a column titled “buy this organic” and “do not buy this organic”, and it was based on the degree of possible contamination. I keep it on my fridge and whenever I can I try to follow it***
In my opinion the organic food industry is becoming a more profit centered business ever since the large spike in organic food consumption. In the past, organic foods were not as popular and thus only found in health food stores, but today they can be found everywhere. Even Walmart! I think many people believe that organic foods are more nutritious, but really I have not found much evidence on this claim, thus large corporations may use this possible misconception to sell their organic products. Large corporations are also aware that some people are more willing to pay more money for organic foods, thus I believe that in some cases prices may not actually reflect the value or quality received from purchasing an organic product.
As discussed in class, organic food consumption which was largely advocated by grassroots movements, is becoming dominated by larger corporations. Most grocery stores now carry organic foods, thus organic foods may eventually no longer be associated with sustainability and environmentally-friendly practices, but they may become part of the unconscious, dissociated grocery store ‘environment’ which is no longer connected to its natural roots. Also, organic foods are starting to dominate the processed food sector. Since, many people associate organic foods with “healthy” food, does this mean that processed organic foods will come to be thought of as “healthy” compared to their non-organic counterpart? They will likely still contain the same amount of sugar, sodium and saturated fat, so is it really beneficial to the population to make processed foods organic? In my opinion, it is not. I think this movement is largely driven by money hungry corporations, that use profit as their main goal.
My last point for a possible con related to organic foods involves land use. I know organic farming is known for its sustainability, but how can it ever be more efficient than conventional farming? Without the use of chemicals or growth hormones wouldn't the yields of organic farmers be much less than those of conventional farmers? Thus, wouldn’t organic farmers need more land? So, with the increased demand for organic food, will an increase in land use for agricultural purposes also increase? Will this mean that forests and other valuable land will have to be transformed into agricultural land? I do not know the answers to these questions, but they are definitely questions that make me wonder about the future of organic farming practices.
So, we gave you some of our thoughts on the pros and cons of organic eating. We hope that you found some of them interested and they generated some thoughts of your own. The debate over the advantages and disadvantages of organic foods will likely continue for sometime. What are your thoughts on the subject?
http://dufferinpark.ca/market/pdf/noworganictoronto.PDF
http://www.thedailygreen.com/healthy-eating/eat-safe/Dirty-Dozen-Foods
http://www.thedailygreen.com/healthy-eating/eat-safe/Save-on-Sustainable-Gallery-44032808
http://www.nextnature.net/2008/12/i-want-my-organic-coke/
Canadian Organic Growers: http://www.cog.ca/
Canadian Food Inspection Agency: http://www.inspection.gc.ca/english/fssa/orgbio/orgbioe.shtml
Organic Agriculture Centre of Canada: http://www.organicagcentre.ca/
References
Magkos, F., Arvaniti, F., & A. Zampelas. (2003). Organic food: nutritious food or food for thought? A review of the evidence. International Journal of Food Sciences and Nutrition. 54: 357-371. http://www.informaworld.com/smpp/content~content=a713995042&db=all
The PACT: http://www.pactprogram.ca/pact/Grow_to_Learn.html
http://atlanticfarmfocus.ca/index.cfm?sid=332033&sc=587
No comments:
Post a Comment